Skip to content

She Took Her Sister's Place at the Altar. The Billionaire Groom Already Knew.

Chapter Five

The Princess Won

3 min read

Advertisement
Advertisement

Alexander set a small black recorder on the desk.

"I agreed to that lunch," he said, "because Chloe told me she had something important to tell me about Evie. I didn't trust her. So I recorded it."

He pressed play.

Chloe's voice filled the office. Clear. Laughing. Slightly drunk.

Advertisement

"Come on, Alex. You don't actually love her. She's a nurse. She's boring. Mom and I set the whole thing up. I always planned to come back. Leave her, marry me, and nobody ever has to know about the money Mom and I took from Daddy's company. It's not like he'll ever figure it out. He's an idiot."

Then Alexander's voice on the tape, very calm.

"And if I don't leave her?"

"Then Mom has a friend on the board at Mount Sinai. One complaint about missing medication, and your little nurse never works in a hospital again."

The recording ended.

The office was dead silent.

Advertisement

Pamela's face had gone white. Chloe's mouth was open.

The man from the hospital board looked at Pamela for a very long moment. Then he quietly closed his briefcase.

"I think," he said, "I'll be withdrawing that complaint. And reporting it."

Evie looked at Alexander.

"You didn't pull away from her at lunch," she said slowly.

"Because I needed her to keep talking," Alexander said. "I needed proof. I'm sorry I couldn't tell you. I was afraid that if you knew, it would hurt you more." He came around the desk. "Evie, I would never in my life choose her over you. Not for a second."

Advertisement

Evie opened her folder on his desk.

"Then you'll want this too," she said. "Five years of bank records. PC Ventures. Cayman Islands. Every dollar they took from my father."

Alexander looked down at the folder, then back up at her, and something in his face broke open.

"You figured it out," he said. "On your own."

"A seven-year-old told me to fight the dragon," Evie said.


Gordon Sinclair walked into the office twenty minutes later. Alexander had called him.

He read the bank records standing up. Then he sat down heavily in a chair and stared at his wife.

"Five years," he said. "Five years, I thought I'd failed. I thought I'd destroyed everything my father built. I almost…" His voice cracked. "Pamela, I almost lost my mind last spring."

Pamela didn't say anything.

Gordon turned to his younger daughter.

"Evie," he said. "I let them put you in that dress. I let them treat you like you were nothing. Your whole life." Tears were running down his face. "I'm so ashamed."

Evie knelt down in front of her father and took his hands.

"I know, Daddy," she said softly. "But you're going to be a grandfather. So you're going to have to do better."

Everyone in the room turned to look at her.

Alexander went completely still.

"Evie," he said. "Did you just say…"

She stood up and looked at him and nodded, crying and laughing at the same time.

Alexander Stone, the coldest man on Wall Street, sat down right on the floor of his own office and put his face in his hands and cried.


Pamela and Chloe Sinclair were charged with embezzlement, wire fraud and filing a false report. Chloe's DJ, Rafe, sold his story to Page Six for five thousand dollars. Pamela's divorce was finalized in the spring.

Gordon Sinclair rebuilt his company. Slowly. Honestly. He called Evie every Sunday.

Nana June moved into the guest room of Alexander's penthouse "for a few weeks" and never left.


The baby was born in the fall at Mount Sinai Hospital. A little girl with dark hair and her father's serious expression, until she smiled.

Alexander held her in the hospital room, and he couldn't stop staring at her.

"What do you want to name her?" Evie asked.

He looked down at their daughter for a long time.

Then he reached into his jacket pocket and took out something small and purple. A tiny knit hat, the size of a baby's fist. He'd had it made from the yarn of his sister's old hat.

He put it gently on his daughter's head.

"Lucy," he said. "If that's alright with you."

Evie reached over and took his hand.

"It's perfect," she said.

And down the hall, in the pediatric cancer ward, a seven-year-old girl named Maya, whose leukemia had just gone into remission, was telling all the other kids that the quiet princess had won.

The End

Your turn

Would you have forgiven Evie's parents?

Leave a comment on the Facebook post where you found this story.

Loved it? Share it with a friend